ATAILA Newsroom · Budapest ·
2026-W41
The Dutch tax office drops the Microsoft 365 cloud. Capacity came first.
When a Hungarian buyer asks what digital sovereignty means in practice, the conversation usually starts with software: which suite, which model, which cloud. On 5 October the Dutch State Secretary for Finance put a different order on the record. The tax administration can leave the Microsoft 365 cloud, he wrote, partly because it has enlarged its own data-centre capacity, and taking a supplier's hosting in-house for a new VAT system has already moved two go-live dates. We read the signed letter, not only the headline, and we say where the comparison with a Hungarian company breaks down.
The article we are responding to
“Dutch tax office ditches Microsoft 365 cloud for on-premises alternative”
The Register, 7 October 2026
What the letter says
On 5 October 2026 Eelco Eerenberg, State Secretary for Finance, sent the Tweede Kamer a letter on the future-proofing of the Belastingdienst, the Dutch tax administration (Kamerstuk 31066-1579). It answers written questions that the CDA member Van Dijk put on 8 September, and most of it is about the administration's IT portfolio. One section covers office automation.
There the State Secretary writes that the Belastingdienst, Customs (Douane) and Benefits (Toeslagen) have reconsidered the choices made in 2025 to modernise and replace the workplace with Microsoft 365. They now choose "een on-premises oplossing in combinatie met open source". In that scenario the software runs on servers of the Belastingdienst, or on servers it controls. His explanation of why this is possible now: "Dat deze optie nu wel mogelijk is, komt mede doordat het de Belastingdienst gelukt is om datacentercapaciteit te vergroten." In our translation: the option is now possible partly because the Belastingdienst has succeeded in enlarging its data-centre capacity.
The timetable has two steps. Mail and calendar go on-premises first, in 2027. European open-source solutions for personal storage and collaboration follow later in 2027 and in 2028. The approach aims to use existing licences as far as possible, to limit additional investment. It follows the advice of the Advisory Council on ICT Assessment (Adviescollege ICT-Toetsing) not to assume one solution from one supplier, and to look for alternatives function by function.
The letter is plain about one cost. Some records-management facilities planned in the Microsoft 365 package are not available on-premises, and the Belastingdienst is still working out what it needs to replace them. The State Secretary promises to return to this in the next state-of-affairs letter at the latest.
A separate passage in the same letter concerns a different system, the new VAT platform. The letter lists geopolitical developments, and the attention to digital autonomy they have brought, among the external factors that move the plan. Its example: by taking over the hosting from the supplier, the Belastingdienst can implement the new system responsibly "in de huidige geopolitieke context". Because this costs extra work, the go-live of VAT-refund moves to April 2027 and the rollout of domestic VAT moves from 1 July 2027 to the third quarter of 2027.
This is an announcement, and the dates it names are in 2027 and 2028. The pause came earlier. The Register reports that in June the advisory council recommended rolling back a Microsoft 365 rollout that had reached about 5,000 of the 47,500 employees across the tax, customs and benefits services.
2027
mail and calendar on-premises, the first step in the State Secretary's letter of 5 October 2026 (Kamerstuk 31066-1579)
2027 and 2028
European open-source solutions for personal storage and collaboration ("Later in 2027 en 2028" in the letter of 5 October 2026)
April 2027 · third quarter of 2027
new go-live of VAT-refund, and the domestic VAT rollout moved from 1 July 2027, after the Belastingdienst took over the supplier's hosting (same letter)
about 55% · 40% · 5%
share of the Belastingdienst's available IT change capacity going to essential modernisation, to legislation and external obligations, and to strategic renewal; the stated aim is at most 20% for modernisation and at least 20% for renewal (same letter)
about 5,000 of the 47,500
employees across tax, customs and benefits already moved to Microsoft 365 when the advisory council recommended a rollback in June, per The Register, 7 October 2026
Two kinds of capacity
The Register's summary says increased data-centre capacity made the on-premises option possible. The letter says "mede", partly. The difference matters less than the order of events. The administration could make the software decision once it had room to run the software itself. The open-source tools arrive in 2027 and 2028. The data-centre space came first.
The second kind of capacity is people. The same letter says that about 55 percent of the available IT change capacity in the portfolio goes to essential modernisation, 40 percent to legislation and external obligations, and "slechts vijf procent", only five percent, to strategic renewal. Bringing the VAT hosting in-house took enough of that capacity to move two go-live dates. The State Secretary has put a price on one piece of sovereignty in a signed document: two moved go-live dates on a tax system, paid in extra work.
The advisory council's objections, as The Register reports them, covered encryption, confidential documents travelling via American servers, lock-in to a single supplier, and the lack of an exit strategy. The Register adds, fairly, that many of the encryption concerns stem from the configuration the administration chose. That leaves lock-in and exit. Neither is solved by picking a different product. Both are solved by having somewhere else to run.
What this means for AI, and for us
The letter is about mail, calendars and file sharing. It is not about AI. The argument carries over anyway, because an AI deployment has the same two layers. The model is the software. The GPUs, the network and the people who keep them running are the capacity. An open-weight model can be downloaded in an afternoon. A place to run it under your own control takes planning, and, as the Dutch found, time.
That is the layer ATAILA sells. ATAILA Cloud runs open-weight models as a managed multi-tenant service on our own hardware in the EU. The Enterprise edition runs single-tenant on the customer's own hardware. Both come with sandbox, dev, uat and prod environments and 99,9% availability. In both, the capacity exists before the customer picks a model, which is the order the Dutch letter describes.
Capacity in the EU is one layer of sovereignty, and only one. The silicon is NVIDIA's, not ours. The other questions behind the word are in Sovereign is not a brand.
Where our reading is weak
Scale. The Belastingdienst is a national tax administration with its own data centres and its own engineers, and The Register counts 47,500 employees across tax, customs and benefits. It still needed to reconsider its 2025 choice, an advisory council review and a letter to parliament. A Hungarian company of 50 people cannot copy that path. For most, the realistic lesson is to rent capacity from someone else, which reopens the question of whose.
Plans. Mail and calendar on-premises in 2027 and open source in 2027 and 2028 are dates in a letter, not running systems. The same letter shows two VAT dates already moving. Records management is unsolved.
A partial exit. The approach reuses existing licences where possible. The letter does not say whose licences. Given that the administration chose Microsoft 365 in 2025, we assume many are Microsoft's; that is our inference, not the letter's. On-premises is not the same as vendor-free.
Not AI. The letter's one mention of AI concerns citizens using generative AI to file more objections. Nothing in it says where the tax administration runs AI models. The AI conclusion above is ours.
One side heard. Microsoft declined to comment to The Register, and we know the advisory council's June report only through The Register's account of it.
What we concede, and what we will be asked
This is a large organisation's case. Most of our Hungarian customers will never build data-centre capacity of their own. Renting ours is a dependency too. It is a smaller one, in the EU, but it is a dependency on us, and we will not describe it otherwise.
A sceptical reader will ask why a company should not keep Microsoft 365 with a stricter configuration, since The Register notes that many of the advisory council's concerns came from the design chosen, or wait for the hyperscalers' sovereign offers. For many companies that will be enough. Our answer is the one in the letter: an exit needs somewhere to go, and that place has to exist before it is needed.
What we commit to. When we discuss sovereignty with a buyer we start from capacity: whose hardware, where, run by whom, at what cost, before we name a model. We will follow the Dutch timetable, including the roadmap the State Secretary promised for the first quarter of 2027 and the 2027 mail and calendar step, and report whether the dates hold.
Sources, figures, and one disclosure
The story we are answering: Dutch tax office ditches Microsoft 365 cloud for on-premises alternative, Richard Speed, The Register, 7 October 2026. Opened and read in full. The figure of about 5,000 of 47,500 employees, the advisory council's June recommendation and its objections, Microsoft's decline to comment, and the comments from Element and Nextcloud are from this article. Nextcloud's statement that it added more than two million sovereign workspace seats in 2025 is a vendor claim, and we do not use it.
The primary source: the letter Toekomstbestendigheid Belastingdienst from E. Eerenberg, staatssecretaris van Financiën, dated 5 October 2026, Kamerstuk 31066-1579, listed on the Tweede Kamer's page and downloaded as the letter document. Opened and read in full, in Dutch. Every Dutch quotation is from it. The English renderings are our translations, and the percentages are given as the letter states them ("ongeveer 55 procent" is about 55 percent).
Not opened: the Adviescollege ICT-Toetsing report of June 2026, for which we rely on The Register; the letter's annexes, including the answers to the written questions and the decision notes (Beslisnota's); and the Politico report on the European Commission's Element deployment that The Register cites. Our research pass found no Hungarian coverage of the decision in one Hungarian-language search.
The disclosure: the inference that the reused licences are largely Microsoft's is ours. The letter says only "bestaande licenties", existing licences.
The original article
“Dutch tax office ditches Microsoft 365 cloud for on-premises alternative”
The Register, 7 October 2026
- Read it live at The Register
- ATAILA archive, captured 22 October 2026
The live page has changed since we captured it.
← Back to the Newsroom Press enquiries: contact us